Quoth Og Mandino

"Tomorrow lies buried with yesterday, think of it no more."

My Authorial Debut

The Thrilling Sequel

Banting Redux: The Tale of the Tape

Three months ago, I went to my doctor and had my fasting bloodwork done. The results that came back were horrible, simply horrible. So I embarked on a program of diet and exercise (aka “Banting”) intended to bring my numbers into closer alignment with, you know, ongoing existence as a human being and all that.

(Click to embiggen)

The particulars of the diet are important to relate, if only because they fly in the face of every tenet of healthy eating that I’ve been taught over the past 30 years. In fact, looking at the percentages, you’d think I was on the royal road to heart-attack city. Over the past three months, I’ve been averaging about 65% of my daily calories from fat. (Closer to 70% lately.) And 22% of it is saturated fat. Pause and let that sink in. It’s just crazy.

As for the rest, I’m averaging about 30% from protein, and 5% from carbs. As you can imagine, I’ve cut out sugar completely. I have also cut out all grains & starchy vegetables. I eat fruit only as an occasional treat, and even then I stick to lower-carb fruits like berries. I eat a few vegetables, but again, only low-carb ones like cabbage, broccoli, cauliflower, etc. Overall caloric intake per day is around 2000 calories — not starvation rations by any means. I did increase my daily exercise to at least 30 minutes every day, 1 hour most days. Embiggen the FitDay screengrab on the left to see my averages over the last 2 months.

Anyway, today I got the results from my most recent round of fasting bloodwork after 3 months of this Banting madness. The results are jaw-dropping. Have a look:

  • My A1C (which is a test taken by diabetics to gauge long-term blood glucose control) dropped from 9.7 to 6.4. (The diabetic goal range is >7.0, but I’ve been in the 5s before and would like to be there again.)
  • My triglycerides dropped from 369 to 174. (The goal range is 30-135)
  • My total cholesterol dropped from 239 to 214. (This one’s particularly interesting, given that I stopped taking cholesterol-lowering statin drugs in May after reading research that showed that the side-effects of statins generally outweigh the benefits for women my age. So this decrease is completely independent of medication.)
  • My coronary risk ratio (the ratio of “bad” cholesterol to “good” cholesterol) fell from 6.39 to 3.4 (The goal range is 1.5-5.5)
  • My VLDL cholesterol (which mainly transports triglycerides) fell from 74 to 35. (The goal range is <40)

The only reading that went up slightly was my LDL cholesterol—from 128 to 138.

There are, of course, many other factors that have to be taken into consideration other than diet. There is the effect of meds, of course … and I have been taking a veritable galaxy of supplements, most of them specifically intended to address my metabolic irregularities. So it’s hard to control for how much impact the diet itself is having vs. all the other elements. I guess I can confirm one thing, based on these numbers … it doesn’t seem to be hurting.

So the Banting shall proceed apace! It will be interesting to see where my numbers are three months hence.

  • RebeccaStefoff

    Wow. This is amazing. Especially since I just finished reading a book that advocated bringing down A1c and cholesterol through a vegan, very low-fat diet. Your program sounds more appealing. So what are you eating to get that 65-70 percent of caloric intake from fat? Meat, cheese,a lot of salmon?

  • http://www.demimonde.com M.K. Hobson

    There is an absolutely fascinating, very controversial book by Lierre Keith called “The Vegetarian Myth” where she talks about how veganism & vegetarianism are not only bad from a health standpoint, but from a global ecological one as well. I'm not sure I buy all her arguments, but I think she's an interesting and important voice.

    As far as where the fat is coming from … BACON! ;-) And eggs, and lots of red meat, for sure. Salmon when I can get it. Heavy whipping cream is a particular favorite, though I do have to be careful with it. The problem with eating a proportionally high fat diet is that the overall calories can get out of hand pretty quickly. You have to work on portion control. But the fat-heavy meals stick with you so you don't feel hungry all the time.

    I really like Mark Sisson (of the Mark's Daily Apple blog) and have adapted my diet from his “paleo” philosophy. Here's a post he did on diabetes, sugar & insulin which is awesome: http://www.marksdailyapple.com/diabetes/

    Also, I don't know if you've read “Good Calories, Bad Calories” by Gary Taubes, but if you haven't … it's an absolute eye opener.

  • http://www.facebook.com/j.kathleen.cheney J. Kathleen Cheney

    Wow. I need to think about this…

  • RebeccaStefoff

    Thanks for this info, Mary. I've been trying (on and off) to follow the basic ADA recommendations, sometimes trying (mostly off) to go vegan in order to resolve my mild Type 2 and ideally lose a pound or two. (I forget the name of the vegan-for-diabetes book I read, but the author was Neal Barnard.) I'm always hungry, though, and my bad sugar habit hasn't gotten any less bad. There's probably no way to whittle it down–I'll need to cut it off at the roots.

    I'm going to check out these leads, but you had me at BACON. I love it and have been missing it. I forget the name of the vegan-for-diabetes book I read, but the author was Neal Barnard. I find your approach far more delicious, er, interesting. Meatloaf is suddenly back on the menu–with bacon strips on top, no less.

    We had some luck getting wild-caught salmon at, of all places, Freddy's for a while. They don't always have it, but when they do, and it's fresh, you can sometimes buy a whole fish and have them filet it for you.

  • AlyxDellamonica

    Three cheers–or even more!–for better health stats. That's great, Mary!

  • hazelwindows

    Wow! It's shocking that the diet breakdown above (particularly the fat %) resulted in such an improvement in health. You weren't, by chance, eating an even higher % fat diet before the Banting diet, were you? How can this be working? I love your straightforward approach to the dietary experiment. Way to follow through!

  • http://www.demimonde.com M.K. Hobson

    Here's an interesting article from today's CNN on low-carb diets: http://pagingdrgupta.blogs.cnn.com/2010/08/02/l…

    Prior to starting my “Banting” program, I was eating pretty normally. Lots of whole wheat bread, brown rice, vegetables & fruit. But I was also eating LOTS of sugar. Lots and lots of sugar. The more sugar I ate, the more I craved.

    So again, I can't really tell what is the relative weight of each of my lifestyle choices. Is the high-fat diet 90% of my success … or is it only 10%, with cutting out sugar being the rest? Or maybe 50% of the success comes from supplements. Or maybe from the additional exercise. I just can't tell, because I've made so many different lifestyle changes.

  • http://musingaloud.livejournal.com/ Pam

    Um, so can I ask? Are you diabetic, or pre-diabetic? I have a friend whose blood sugar went WAY up, she was overweight and had a family history, and she went on the Atkins diet and had the same type of result as you. Weight loss and normal sugar ranges. As a person who grew up living with a diabetic (my father, type 1), I can only say what a horrible disease it is. I watched it progress, saw its impact on all of our lives over the years, and ended up losing him much too young. I think there's a lot of people who consider diabetes “cured” because there's a treatment for it, but the effects of the disease are only controlled and never eliminated. It's tough. I'm glad you're taking care of yourself.

  • http://www.demimonde.com M.K. Hobson

    I am Type II diabetic. I first developed gestational diabetes when I
    was pregnant with my daughter (back in 1998). I wish I'd known then
    what I know today … I might have delayed the onset of full-blown
    diabetes for quite a bit longer. Ah, well.

    Yeah, it's a sucky disease — especially Type I, like your father had.
    Probably the worst thing about Type II is that it comes with a whole
    lot of weight/body image baggage … “well, if you hadn't let yourself
    get so fat, you wouldn't have gotten diabetes.” I have been
    embarrassed to talk about it.

    The thing I found most interesting in Gary Taubes' book “Good
    Calories, Bad Calories” is his assertion that overweight is a symptom
    of ill health (specifically, hormonal dysregulation) as opposed to a
    cause of it. Maybe it's me looking for a rationalization, but that
    really struck a chord with me.

  • http://www.demimonde.com M.K. Hobson

    Here's a secret about bacon … either rinse it in hot water or briefly parboil it before frying. It comes out WAY less salty (and more crispy) and you lose some of the fat. (When I do bacon this way I actually replace the lost fat with a little coconut oil, which has a much better health profile. It turns out DUH-LICIOUS.

    Now, though, you've got me craving salmon. I've seen really nice fillets at Costco, and I do need to make a run over there soon …

  • http://www.naturalcholesterolsupplements.com Lavern Jerowski

    Thank you for your article. im glad i found your website