Quoth Og Mandino

"Do all things with love."

My Authorial Debut

The Thrilling Sequel

My jolly Banting adventures

So one of the things that’s been taking up a lot of my mind space lately is Banting. Which is a term taken from the name of a gentleman named William Banting, who wrote a screed in 1869 called “A Letter on Corpulence” that proved so popular that throughout much of the 19th century, Banting’s name was synonymous with dieting. I am so fascinated by this because, you know, I can’t just be on a diet, I have to be on a 19th century diet.

OK, not really. While I think it’s neato-keen that the dietary guidelines I’m currently following are so closely aligned with advice put forth over 150 years ago, it’s modern-day research (from the likes of Gary Taubes & Dr. Robert Lustig) that sold me. In a nutshell, it’s all about cutting out sugar (natch) as well as breads, grains, and starches. Instead, you eat more meat, fat, and (non-starchy) vegetables. Basically, it’s a lot like the Atkins diet, except you don’t have to shuffle your feet with embarrassment when you talk about it. (The Atkins embarrassment factor, of course, comes from the allowance of sexy, sensual, sinful bacon. Naysayers have a very hard time getting past the bacon element. You tell people you’re on a diet and you eat bacon, they look at you like you’ve just told them you’re entering rehab for sex addiction while carrying a suitcase full of vibrators.)

Well, anyway, bacon notwithstanding, my experiments with “Banting” have worked pretty well so far. I’ve lost weight, but I’m actually trying not to focus on that aspect of my Banting adventure (What? INSANITY!) What I really care about is my blood glucose—which is under way better control. Funny how not eating sugar will help with that!

I could go on, but Mr. Banting does it way better than I do:

My former dietary table was bread and milk for breakfast, or a pint of tea with plenty of milk, sugar, and buttered toast; meat, beer, much bread (of which I was always very fond) and pastry for dinner, the meal of tea similar to that of breakfast, and generally a fruit tart or bread and milk for supper. I had little comfort and far less sound sleep.

It certainly appears to me that my present dietary table is far superior to the former—more luxurious and liberal, independent of its blessed effect—but when it is proved to be more healthful, comparisons are simply ridiculous, and I can hardly imagine that any man, even in sound health, would choose the former, even if it were not an enemy; but, when it is shown to be, as in my case, inimical both to health and comfort, I can hardly conceive there is any man who would not willingly avoid it. I can conscientiously assert that I never lived so well as under the new plan of dietary, which I should have formerly thought a dangerous extravagant trespass upon health ; I am very much better, bodily and mentally, pleased to believe that I hold the reins of health and comfort in my own hands, and, though at seventy-two years of age, I cannot expect to remain free from some coming natural infirmity that all flesh is heir to, I cannot at the present time complain of any.

  • http://www.facebook.com/pclare Patrick Clare

    Nutritionists are leaning towards a diet lower in sugar rather than fat. As it turns out, sugar gets turned into fat more than fat does…stupid bodies.

  • http://serge-lj.livejournal.com/ Serge

    sexy, sensual, sinful bacon

    Lusting after Roger Bacon again?

  • http://serge-lj.livejournal.com/ Serge

    sexy, sensual, sinful bacon

    Lusting after Roger Bacon again?

  • ada

    I'm actually doing this too, because I've heard that sugar can increase inflammation and I'm trying to deal with my chronic tendinitis.

    I know the term banting from an Agatha Christie mystery where someone doesn't eat the poisoned oysters because she's banting.

    • Guest

      It seems that cutting out sugar is beneficial for a whole host of
      ailments. Damn the luck.

      And I would think oysters would be good when you’re Banting! If Dame
      Agatha had made them poisoned cupcakes, I would have bought it. ;-)

      : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : :
      ~ : : ~ : :

      M.K. Hobson : mkhobson@demimonde.com
      http://www.demimonde.com : mkhobson.livejournal.com
      (503) 548-8765 cell : (503) 342-2922 office
      skype ID: mary_hobson

      : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : : ~ : :
      ~ : :

  • http://www.demimonde.com M.K. Hobson

    *edited*

    It seems that cutting out sugar is beneficial for a whole host of
    ailments. Damn the luck.

    And I would think oysters would be good when you're Banting! If Dame
    Agatha had made them poisoned cupcakes, I would have bought it. ;-)

  • http://www.demimonde.com M.K. Hobson

    I'm more of a Francis Bacon gal, myself. But as long as it's fried and crispy, I'll hit it.

  • http://www.demimonde.com M.K. Hobson

    I've been totally off sugar for a few months now (not counting the few bites of desserts I had while in NYC, and the piece of yummy yummy cheesecake) and most of the time it's OK. Being off bread & grains is way harder.

    I've always thought I'd be a bad candidate for bariatric surgery because I was so hooked on sugar. But now I know I can give it up, a whole new set of options opens up for me. Now the lottery win just has to come through and I'll be golden!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=756614809 Simone Cooper

    Please, please do not go for the surgery. The risk of serious complications, while low, (less than 3 in 100), it is high for something elective.

    The banting program you are on is actually similar to the most well-supported programs. The BBC did a great documentary on the state of knowledge today. It's about 60 minutes long, and it is posted here in ten-minute segments:
    http://documentaryheaven.com/10-things-you-need…

    While it is somewhat simplified for the audience, it shows how higher protein (but lower fat _and_ calorie conscious) programs that have good fiber and nutritional content contribute to overall weight loss in the longer term. It also talks scientifically about cravings–how they are modulated in the brain and things that reduce or stimulate them. Well done, BBC!

    Fascinating stuff! And as near to the balanced, “lifestyle change” approach that has been most effective in the long term as any advice I've seen.

    PS: Increasing protein and spreading protein consumption throughout the day is generally recommended. Socking down protein, especially high-fat protein as “recommended” by some people's reading of the Atkins diet, is harmful in several specific ways, especially over the long term. Unfortunately it also–at first–speeds weight loss, and so some people still think it is a magic pill.

  • http://www.demimonde.com M.K. Hobson

    Please, please do not go for the surgery. The risk of serious
    complications, while low, (less than 3 in 100), it is high for
    something elective.

    Yeah, I hear you about the complications. And I would be in complete
    agreement if my only goal was to look better in a pair of blue jeans.
    But when I look at the much-higher probability of nasty health
    complications arising from long-term diabetes (which becomes harder to
    control as I get older) I'd probably go for the surgery.

    Not that it's likely to happen, mind you. My chances of ever having
    $10,000+ bucks just lying around (as well as enough money to pay for
    the required follow up care afterward) are pretty slim.

  • http://twitter.com/Jamiescribbles : Jamie Mason

    This is very interesting stuff. The notable quackery of the age aside, there were some fascinating strides (and stumbles) in the cult of wellness.

    Check out this guy, fer instance:

    http://www.amazon.com/Mucusless-Healing-System-…

    Ehret pulled together this diet initially to help mental patients. It didn't cure their various manias (maniases? manii? mani-asus?), but they sure got skinny fast. The diet itself is basically: no bread, no sugar, no salt, no starch, no meat, no dairy products. Just fruit and veggies. And water. Period.

    I used it myself. Works like a charm. You get light-headed and, after about a month, do a lotta dry heaving. But man, you slim down.

    Anyway – good luck with your diet.